Best Shoes for Hammertoe: Support, Comfort, and Pain Relief

Last Updated on May 11, 2025 by Andy Walker

Hammertoe can make every step painful, especially in the wrong shoes. Choosing the right footwear can help relieve discomfort, prevent the condition from worsening, and even make walking enjoyable again. Whether you’re managing mild symptoms or post-surgical recovery, this guide highlights the best shoe options for people with hammertoes.

See also: Best Shoes for Bunions

Comparison Table: Best Shoes for Hammertoes

Here’s a quick overview of the best shoes for hammertoe issues, with specific features that make them ideal for this foot condition:

Detailed Reviews for Best Shoes for Hammertoes

Here are our reviews of the best shoes if you have a hammertoe.

Orthofeet Coral Stretch Knit (Women)

Best for: All-day wear, severe hammertoe

Orthofeet’s Coral Stretch Knit is one of the most recommended shoes for women with hammertoes, thanks to its unique combination of comfort, support, and protection. The stretchy knit upper accommodates toe deformities without causing friction or pressure, while the deep, wide toe box allows the toes to spread naturally. It includes a premium orthotic insole with anatomical arch support and a cushioned heel pad, which helps reduce pressure on the forefoot. This model is ideal for women who are on their feet most of the day or who suffer from additional foot issues like bunions, plantar fasciitis, or diabetes. The rocker-bottom sole also promotes a smoother walking gait, which further eases toe joint stress. While it may not win any fashion awards, it’s a powerhouse of therapeutic features and comes in multiple widths for a custom fit. For severe hammertoe, the Coral provides a pain-free walking experience.

Specs

• Stretch knit upper,
• Orthotic insole,
• Deep and wide toe box,
• Mild rocker sole,
• Multiple widths available

Pros

• Exceptional cushioning and support
• Excellent for multiple foot issues
• Accommodates foot swelling and deformities

Cons

• Bulky silhouette
• Limited color options

Orthofeet Edgewater Stretch for Men

Best for: All-day wear, severe hammertoe

The Orthofeet Edgewater Stretch for men delivers the same therapeutic benefits as its women’s counterpart but with a masculine design. It features a stretchable knit upper that gently conforms to the foot’s shape, making it ideal for men with hammertoes, bunions, or swelling. The shoe is extra deep and wide at the front, reducing pressure on curled toes while promoting a more natural foot posture. Its interior is fully padded and seam-free, preventing irritation—especially useful for diabetic users or those with sensitive feet. The orthotic insole provides arch support and heel cushioning, while the lightweight sole has a mild rocker design that encourages better stride mechanics. Although more utilitarian than stylish, the Edgewater is built for all-day wear and lasting comfort. It’s especially helpful for those who require medical-grade footwear for daily activities or long shifts on their feet.

Specs

• Stretch knit upper
• deep toe box,
• anatomical orthotic insole,
• padded seam-free interior,
• mild rocker bottom

Pros

• Reduces pressure on hammertoes
• Custom-like fit for foot deformities
• Orthotic support built-in

Cons

• Bulky profile
• Design skews orthopedic

New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14

Best for: Walking, running, athletic use

The 1080v14 is the latest in New Balance’s flagship Fresh Foam line, offering maximum cushioning and support for active individuals. This model stands out for its wide forefoot and soft, responsive cushioning—both ideal for people with hammertoes. The engineered mesh upper provides stretch and breathability, adapting comfortably to swollen or bent toes. Unlike purely orthopedic shoes, this running shoe blends athletic aesthetics with performance, making it a go-to option for fitness enthusiasts with foot issues. The 1080v14 also comes in wide sizes, and its cushioned midsole absorbs impact during walking or jogging. Its flexible forefoot design allows for natural toe movement, reducing irritation on affected joints. Though premium-priced, the 1080v14 delivers outstanding value in terms of comfort, durability, and hammertoe-friendly fit.

Specs

• Fresh Foam X midsole
• Engineered mesh upper
• 6mm heel drop
• Wide toe box
• Wide size availability

Pros

• Plush and responsive ride
• Accommodates active users with hammertoe
• Athletic style with comfort tech

Cons

• Runs a bit long
• Pricier than average

Altra Escalante 4

Best for: Active wear, wide toe splay

The Altra Escalante 4 is a dream for wearers who prioritize natural foot alignment and toe splay. With Altra’s signature FootShape toe box and zero-drop platform, this shoe promotes a more balanced gait while taking pressure off the front of the foot. That’s great news for hammertoe sufferers. The knit upper is both breathable and flexible, offering gentle support without compressing the toes. Unlike orthopedic shoes that focus purely on comfort, the Escalante is stylish enough for gym wear, errands, and casual settings. It’s lightweight and nimble underfoot, with moderate cushioning and decent ground feel. The zero-drop profile may take some adjustment for new users, but those used to minimalist or barefoot-style shoes will appreciate the control. This is an excellent option for walkers, runners, or anyone needing more toe space.

Specs

• Zero-drop platform
• Engineered knit upper
• FootShape design
• Moderate cushioning

Pros

• Wide toe box encourages natural splay
• Lightweight and flexible
• Casual style for daily wear

Cons

• Not ideal for overpronators
• Lower arch support than structured shoes

Men’s version | Women’s version

Dr. Comfort William X for Men

Best for: Therapeutic and diabetic support

The William X from Dr. Comfort is a heavy-duty therapeutic shoe designed with hammertoe and other foot deformities in mind. The double-depth structure allows for custom orthotics and ample room for swelling or pronounced toe bends. Made with durable leather, it features a protective toe box and a smooth, seam-free lining to reduce friction and skin irritation. This shoe is especially helpful for diabetic patients or seniors who require medical-grade footwear with orthopedic features. The padded heel and tongue enhance comfort, while the hook-and-loop closure allows easy adjustments for fit. While not sleek or trendy, the William X offers peace of mind for those seeking stability, safety, and all-day relief.

Specs

• Double-depth leather upper
• Seamless interior
• Hook-and-loop closure
• Removable footbed
• Extra-wide options

Pros

• Built for foot protection
• Good for post-op or severe cases
• Diabetic-friendly design

Cons

• Bulky and formal-looking
• Limited casual use

Dr. Comfort Annie X (Women)

Best for: Therapeutic and diabetic support

The Annie X is Dr. Comfort’s women’s version of the William X, delivering the same double-depth build and medical-grade comfort. This shoe is ideal for women with hammertoes, diabetes, arthritis, or foot sensitivity. Its roomy toe box prevents crowding, while the seamless lining protects against irritation. The Velcro closure allows for easy on-off and fit adjustment. Like its men’s counterpart, the Annie X is approved for Medicare reimbursement and works well with custom orthotics. It’s best suited for women seeking reliable, therapeutic footwear for daily use, recovery, or chronic foot issues. Though utilitarian in appearance, it performs where it matters most—comfort and function.

Specs

• Double-depth upper
• Seamless padded interior
• Velcro closure
• Removable insoles
• Extra-wide sizing

Pros

• Excellent for medical needs
• Works with custom orthotics
• Reduces hammertoe pressure

Cons

• Conservative style
• Not ideal for dress wear

Propét TravelActiv Stretch for Women

Best for: Casual wear, travel, flexibility

For women who want something lightweight, affordable, and easy to wear, the Propét TravelActiv Stretch is a solid choice. The stretch knit upper molds comfortably around hammertoes without adding pressure, making it suitable for travel, errands, or casual work settings. It’s breathable and machine washable—ideal for people with foot issues who need convenient daily footwear. The EVA sole keeps it light and cushioned underfoot, and wide widths are available to ensure a relaxed fit. While it doesn’t offer the medical-level support of other shoes on this list, it’s a great budget-friendly option for mild to moderate hammertoe discomfort.

Specs

• Stretch mesh upper
• EVA sole
• Slip-on style
• Padded collar
• Machine washable

Pros

• Light and travel-ready
• Accommodates hammertoe pain
• Affordable price point

Cons

• Limited support
• Only available in women’s sizes