Quick Answer: Best Winter Boots for Icy Sidewalks: No boot guarantees it, but these four passed a lab slip test on wet and cold ice. Our top pick is the women’s Keen Revel IV Mid Polar. In the WinterLab test at Toronto’s KITE Research Institute, it held grip up to a 10-degree slope, the best result on this list. For an ankle-height errand boot, choose the Baffin Telluride. Men who want a tall side-zip boot should look at the Baffin Ice Hero. For icy parking lots without a full boot, the unisex Shoes For Crews Brakly passed too. A measured ice score tells you more than deep tread. Compare all four in the table below.
Will a winter boot keep you upright on an icy sidewalk? No boot can promise that. A few have measured grip on ice, and most do not. Our top pick, the women’s Keen Revel IV Mid Polar, has the highest WinterLab score among the boots on this list, and that score covers both wet and cold ice.
That test comes from WinterLab, a cold room at Toronto’s KITE Research Institute, part of University Health Network. Testers in a safety harness walk on an ice floor while the floor slowly tilts, until their boots slip. A boot has to hold on a 7-degree slope, about as steep as an accessible curb ramp, to earn one SnowFlake, the lab’s lowest passing grade. When the first ratings came out in 2016, only 8% of the 98 boots tested met that bar.
This list is for walkers who deal with icy sidewalks, parking lots and driveways. Our best winter boots guide covers more boots, but it picks for warmth and waterproofing, not measured ice grip. Not sure what suits your feet? Try our free Shoe Finder.
Our picks at a glance
| Shoe (click to jump to review below) | Best for | Key feature for icy sidewalks | Price & availability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keen Revel IV Mid Polar (Women's) | Strongest measured ice grip in a hiker-style boot | WinterLab score 10; 13 degrees on wet ice | Check latest price |
| Baffin Telluride (Women's) | Ankle-height boot for errands | WinterLab score 9; 11 degrees on wet ice | Check latest price |
| Baffin Ice Hero (Men's) | Tall side-zip boot for long hours outside | WinterLab score 8; 11 degrees uphill on wet ice | Check latest price |
| Shoes For Crews Brakly | Icy lots and commutes without a full boot | WinterLab score 9; even results on wet and cold ice | Check latest price |
How we chose: only boots that passed WinterLab’s slip test
What the scores mean: Every pick has a passing score on WinterLab’s Rate My Treads Winter Casual list and a current listing from its brand or a U.S. retailer. We ranked them by that score, then checked each one against brand and retailer specs. Under the lab’s published test method, a boot’s score is its worst result across four testers, wet and cold ice, and uphill and downhill walking. A score of 7 to 10 degrees earns one SnowFlake, 11 to 14 earns two, and 15 or more earns three. We did not test these boots ourselves. WinterLab tests boots new, so grip may change as the rubber wears. Learn more about how we review shoes.
Only four boots made this list, and that is on purpose. In WinterLab’s Winter Casual list, most passing boots are Canadian store brands such as WindRiver, Denver Hayes and Woods, sold at Mark’s in Canada. Plenty of popular boots score below a pass, so we did not pad the list with them.
Keen Revel IV Mid Polar (Women’s)
Best for: women who want the strongest measured ice grip in a hiker-style boot
The women’s Keen Revel IV Mid Polar scored 10 in WinterLab’s test, the highest score on this list. That equals one SnowFlake. It is a pass, not the lab’s top grade of three SnowFlakes. Its wet-ice results were stronger still, at 13 degrees walking both uphill and downhill. Wet ice is the slick, glazed kind you find on a sidewalk after a thaw, so that number speaks straight to the question of staying upright on your street.
Retail listings at REI and Scheels describe a hiker-style boot with a Keen Dry waterproof membrane, 200 grams of Keen Warm insulation and a Polar Traction rubber sole with 5 mm lugs that point in several directions. In plain terms, it is an insulated, mid-height lace-up boot. The lugs alone do not tell you how it grips ice. The lab score does. Scheels sells it as women’s style 1023629, the same style number WinterLab tested.
The score has limits. WinterLab tested this boot in December 2020, and the Revel IV Mid Polar cut for men scored only 7 in a separate WinterLab test. That is a pass, but just barely. Treat the 10 as a result for this exact boot only, not a promise for every Revel model. For more from the brand, see our Keen shoes guide.
Skip it if you want a quick slip-on boot or a tall boot for deep drifts. Men who want the highest score here should look at the Shoes For Crews Brakly, which scored 9. For a tall boot, the Baffin Ice Hero scored 8.
This is the pick for women who walk icy sidewalks often and want the best lab-measured grip here. The trade-off is an older test and a lace-up fit.
Pros
- Highest WinterLab score on this list, so you get more grip margin on sloped, icy paths
- 13 degrees on wet ice, its best condition, which matters on thawing sidewalks
- Insulated and waterproof per retail listings, so one boot covers cold and slush
- Lace-up, mid-height hiker build, per retail listings
Cons
- Tested December 2020; later versions may differ
- Lace-up fit takes longer to put on than a pull-on or zip boot
Here are the key specs, from retail listings and WinterLab:
- WinterLab score (women’s): 10, one SnowFlake
- Wet ice: 13 degrees uphill, 13 downhill
- Cold ice: 10 degrees uphill, 10 downhill
- Waterproofing: Keen.Dry membrane
- Upper: leather and mesh
- Insulation: 200 g Keen.Warm
- Insole: Thermal Heat Shield
- Outsole: Keen Polar Traction rubber, 5 mm multidirectional lugs
Men’s version | Women’s version
Baffin Telluride (Women’s)
Best for: an ankle-height women’s boot for errands on icy streets
The Baffin Telluride is the boot for quick trips: the grocery store, the mailbox, the walk to the bus stop. It scored 9 in WinterLab’s test, one SnowFlake. Its wet-ice results reached 11 degrees in both directions, a little better than its cold-ice results.
According to Baffin, the boot features a 6.5-inch height, a leather upper, a waterproof B-Tek membrane and an IceBite Grip rubber outsole. At that height it sits around the ankle, so there is less boot to pull on.
Sizing needs care. Baffin says the Telluride runs small and advises going one full size up. That matters even more if your feet swell during the day or you wear thick socks. WinterLab tested it in September 2021.
Skip it if you walk through deep, unplowed snow, because a 6.5-inch shaft will let snow in over the top. If you want the most grip, the Keen Revel IV Mid Polar scored higher.
The Telluride suits women who want a passing ice score in a lower, easier boot. The trade-off is less height for deep snow and sizing that runs small.
Pros
- Passing WinterLab score of 9, with 11 degrees on wet ice
- Ankle height is easier to slip on and wear around town
- Waterproof membrane and leather upper handle slush on short trips
Cons
- Runs small, per Baffin, so you will likely need a full size up
- 6.5-inch shaft is too low for deep snow
- Women’s only, so men need a different pick
Here are the key specs, from Baffin and WinterLab:
- WinterLab score: 9, one SnowFlake
- Wet ice: 11 degrees uphill, 11 downhill
- Cold ice: 9 degrees uphill, 10 downhill
- Height: 6.5 inches
- Weight: 3.43 lb per pair (Baffin, women’s 7)
- Upper: leather
- Waterproofing: B-Tek membrane
- Outsole: IceBite Grip rubber
- Fit: runs small; Baffin advises one full size up
Baffin Ice Hero (Men’s)
Best for: men who spend long hours outside and want a tall, side-zip boot
Baffin built the Ice Hero for first responders and emergency crews, people who stand and walk on ice for hours. The plain-toe men’s version scored 8 in WinterLab, one SnowFlake, with 11 degrees uphill on wet ice. WinterLab tested it in April 2026, the most recent test on this list. Later versions may differ.
Baffin lists a 10-inch height, waterproof leather with a B-Tek Dry membrane, a waterproof side zipper and a multi-layer inner boot, plus the same IceBite Grip outsole as the Telluride. The zipper is helpful here. You can get a tall boot on and off without unlacing, which helps if bending is hard or you change footwear at work.
Baffin says it fits true to size and suggests going up if you wear a half size.
Skip it if you mostly walk short distances around town. A tall, insulated work boot is more than you need there. Men who want a lower option for quick errands should look at the Shoes For Crews Brakly instead.
The Ice Hero suits men who are outside for long stretches in snow and ice. The trade-off is a big, specialist boot with limited stock.
Pros
- Most recent WinterLab test on this list, from April 2026
- 10-inch shaft keeps snow out on unplowed paths
- Waterproof side zip makes a tall boot easy to take on and off
- Fixed-fit multi-layer inner boot, per Baffin
Cons
- Lowest score of our four picks at 8, so less grip margin than the Keen
- Built for emergency work, so it is more boot than most errands need
- Baffin’s own store listed it as sold out in November 2026
Here are the key specs, from Baffin and WinterLab:
- WinterLab score: 8, one SnowFlake
- Wet ice: 11 degrees uphill, 9 downhill
- Cold ice: 9 degrees uphill, 8 downhill
- Height: 10 inches
- Upper: waterproof leather
- Waterproofing: B-Tek Dry membrane, waterproof side zipper
- Liner: fixed-fit multi-layer inner boot
- Outsole: IceBite Grip rubber
- Fit: true to size; size up for half sizes, per Baffin
Shoes For Crews Brakly
Best for: commuters and workers who cross icy lots but do not need a full boot
Not everyone wants to wear a big boot all day. The Shoes For Crews Brakly is a slip-resistant work shoe, and it still scored 9 in WinterLab’s test. What stands out is how even its results were: 9 to 10 degrees on wet ice and on cold ice, uphill and down. There is no weak direction, which helps on a sloped parking lot or a ramp into work.
Shoes For Crews describes the Brakly as a shoe with a full-grain leather, water-resistant upper, a padded collar and tongue, a removable foam insole and its 4SG slip-resistant outsole with TripGuard, and the brand sells one version for everyone. Its work-shoe design may suit people moving between parking lots and indoor floors. If you work on your feet, our non-slip work shoes guide has more options.
Note: This shoe is not insulated and is water-resistant rather than waterproof. It is a shoe, not a boot, so snow can get in over the collar. WinterLab tested it in February 2024.
Skip it if you walk a long way in deep snow or very cold weather. Pair it with warm socks, such as one of our heated sock picks.
The Brakly suits people who need ice grip on the way in but spend most of the day indoors. The trade-off is very little protection from cold and deep snow.
Pros
- Passing WinterLab score of 9 with even results in every condition
- Slip-resistant work-shoe design, per Shoes For Crews, for people who move between icy lots and indoor floors
- One version for everyone, per the brand
- Removable insole leaves room for your own insert
Cons
- No insulation, so feet get cold on longer walks
- Water-resistant, not waterproof, so slush can soak through
- Low shoe height lets snow in over the top
Here are the key specs, from Shoes For Crews and WinterLab:
- WinterLab score: 9, one SnowFlake
- Wet ice: 9 degrees uphill, 10 downhill
- Cold ice: 10 degrees uphill, 9 downhill
- Type: slip-resistant work shoe, unisex
- Upper: full-grain leather, water-resistant
- Insulation: none
- Insole: removable open-cell PU
- Outsole: 4SG slip-resistant with TripGuard
What to look for in a winter boot for ice
Before you buy, keep these points in mind:
- A measured ice score beats a traction name. Brand terms for grippy rubber do not tell you how a boot does on a tilted ice floor.
- Look at both ice types. WinterLab tests wet and cold ice, and some well-known boots, such as the Sorel Caribou, score zero on wet ice.
- Deep lugs help in snow, not always on ice. Smooth ice gives tread little to bite into.
- Cleats are an add-on for hard ice. The Korkers Ice Runner cleat scored 9 in WinterLab’s spike category. Take cleats off indoors, where metal studs can slip on hard floors.
- Grip can fade as the rubber wears, so a boot that has gone smooth underfoot may not match its lab score.
Want boots for hiking or work as well? Our best boots hub covers winter, hiking and work picks.
Frequently asked questions about buying winter boots for ice
No. Even the boots that pass WinterLab's test held only up to a certain slope before slipping, and none of the boots on this page reaches the lab's top grade of three SnowFlakes, which starts at 15 degrees. A passing score means better odds on an icy sidewalk, not a guarantee. Slow down, take shorter steps and use handrails where you can.
Because a boot can grip one and not the other. The Sorel Caribou, for example, scored 5 degrees uphill on cold ice but zero on wet ice. Other boots, including the women's Keen Revel IV Mid Polar and the Baffin Telluride on this list, did better on wet ice than on cold ice. WinterLab uses the worse result as the boot's score.
Cleats can add grip on hard ice, and the Korkers Ice Runner scored 9 in WinterLab's spike category, about the same as our passing boots. The catch is that you have to put them on and take them off, and the studs can slip on indoor floors. A passing boot for daily use plus cleats for the worst days covers both.
Not well, by WinterLab's measure. The men's Sorel Caribou scored zero overall, with zero on wet ice in both directions. Other well-known boots fell short too: the Merrell Moab 3 and Sorel 1964 Pac Nylon WP each scored 3. These boots may still be warm and waterproof, but they did not pass the ice test.
Not reliably. Deep lugs dig into snow, but smooth ice gives them little to grab. The rubber compound and sole design matter a lot, which is why a low work shoe like the Brakly passed while some tall, deep-treaded boots did not.
There is no set number. WinterLab tests boots new, and grip depends on how much you walk, the surfaces you cover and how the rubber wears. Replace your boots or add cleats when the tread looks worn smooth, the sole feels slick, or the boot no longer feels stable on slippery ground.
No. The men's Keen Revel IV Mid Polar scored 7 in its own WinterLab test, the lowest passing score, while the women's version scored 10. Both pass, but the women's boot has more grip margin. The highest-scoring pick here that men can wear is the unisex Shoes For Crews Brakly, at 9. For a tall boot, the Baffin Ice Hero scored 8.





