Quick Answer: Choose low-cut hiking shoes for most day hikes and mixed trails, hiking boots when you need more protection or weather coverage, and trail-running shoes when low weight and flexibility matter most. For BWF readers, the Merrell Moab 3 is the classic all-around hiker, the HOKA Anacapa 2 Low GTX is a cushioned waterproof option, and the Merrell Moab Speed 2 is a lighter hybrid. The right choice depends on terrain, load, weather and fit—not simply whether a shoe is labeled “hiking.”
BestWalkingFeet has dozens of trail, hiking, waterproof and boot reviews. This page brings that coverage together so you can start with the type of terrain you face, then move into the detailed guides and model reviews that fit your needs.
Start With the Type of Hiking Footwear
Footwear | Best for | Main advantage | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|---|
Hiking shoes | Day hikes, mixed terrain, travel | Lighter and more flexible than boots | Less ankle and weather coverage |
Hiking boots | Rough terrain, colder weather, heavier loads | Protection and coverage | More weight and bulk |
Trail-running shoes | Fast hiking, light packs, technical movement | Low weight and agile ride | Less protection than a traditional boot |
Waterproof hiking shoes | Cold rain, wet grass, muddy trails | Helps keep outside moisture out | Warmer and slower to dry if water gets inside |
Best Hiking Shoe Reviews on BestWalkingFeet
These are the current hiking-focused models to start with:
- Merrell Moab 3 review — a traditional hiking shoe available in low, waterproof and mid versions.
- HOKA Anacapa 2 Low GTX review — cushioned waterproof hiking footwear for people who prefer a softer ride.
- Merrell Moab Speed 2 review — a lighter hiking/trail hybrid.
- Salomon X Ultra 5 Mid GORE-TEX review — a more protective mid-height waterproof option.
- Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof review — a traditional waterproof hiking boot.
Choose by Terrain and Use
For maintained dirt paths and day hikes, a low-cut hiking shoe usually provides enough traction and protection without the weight of a boot. If your routes include loose rock, roots and uneven ground, prioritize outsole grip, a secure heel and enough underfoot protection that sharp surfaces do not dominate the ride.
For faster movement or routes that blend walking and running, see our best trail walking shoes and men’s trail-running shoe guide. Our trail-running shoes vs. hiking shoes comparison explains where the categories overlap.
Traction Matters More Than Lug Depth Alone
Deep lugs can help in mud and soft ground, but rubber compound, lug shape and the amount of outsole contact also matter. A sticky outsole can perform well on wet rock even with less aggressive lugs. For a deeper explanation, read what a Vibram outsole is and how Vibram rubber works.
Waterproof or Breathable?
Waterproof membranes make sense in cold rain, wet grass and snow, but they reduce ventilation. In warm weather or on routes with stream crossings, a breathable non-waterproof shoe can be easier to live with because it drains and dries faster. See our waterproof trail-running shoe guide if wet-weather protection is the priority.
Hiking Shoes for Flat Feet and Other Fit Needs
Foot shape can matter more than brand. If you need a broader platform or more structured support, start with our best hiking shoes for flat feet. For people who regularly struggle with fit, our wide toe-box shoe guide and wide-feet guide can help narrow the field.
Hiking Shoe Fit Checklist
- Your heel should stay secure on climbs.
- Your toes should not hit the front of the shoe on descents.
- The forefoot should have enough room to spread without sliding side to side.
- Try hiking footwear with the socks you plan to wear on the trail.
- Do not buy a painful shoe and assume it will stretch enough to fix a bad fit.
Hiking Boots and Winter Options
If you need more coverage than a hiking shoe provides, use our Best Boots hub and best winter boots guide. Those pages cover insulated, waterproof and work-oriented footwear in addition to trail use.
Hiking Footwear FAQ
Are hiking shoes better than boots? Neither is universally better. Shoes are lighter and more flexible; boots provide more coverage and protection.
Can trail-running shoes be used for hiking? Yes. Many hikers use trail runners, especially with lighter packs and on routes where agility matters more than heavy protection.
Do hiking shoes need to be waterproof? No. Waterproofing is useful in cold, wet conditions, while breathable non-waterproof shoes can be better in heat or when the shoe is likely to get fully submerged.